Free Shipping & 14 Day Returns Free Shipping & 14 Day Returns

New Arrivals
Engagement
Bands
Jewelry
Custom

Book an Appointment
Contact
About
Standards

New Arrivals
Engagement Rings
Wedding Bands
Jewelry

Contact Us
Book An Appointment
Return Policy
About Us
Account
Wishlist

Collection

View All
Vintage Engagement Rings
Engagement Rings By Erstwhile
Vintage Tiffany & Co.
Custom & Stone Reset
Sold

Era

Victorian
Edwardian
Art Deco
Mid Century

Setting

Solitare
Three Stone
Cluster
Halo
Bezel
Navette

Cut

Old European Cut
Old Mine Cushion Cut
Emerald Cut
Asscher Cut
Marquise Cut
Rose Cut

Metal

Platinum
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
Two Tone

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Vintage Engagement Rings

Collection

Vintage Bands
Erstwhile Bands
Bands for Him

Metal

Platinum Bands
Blackened Metal Bands
Gold Bands
Rose Gold Bands

Style

Eternity Bands
Diamond Bands
Plain Bands
Sapphire Bands

Erstwhile Bands

Vintage

All Vintage Jewelry
Vintage Cocktail Rings
Vintage Necklaces
Vintage Bracelets
Vintage Earrings

By Erstwhile

All Jewelry By Erstwhile

About

Custom Design Process
Custom Engagement Ring Gallery
Customizable Settings

Hand wearing a platinum vintage inspired wedding band and engagement ring on a light background

Hand wearing a platinum vintage inspired wedding band and engagement ring on a light background

Wedding Bands

Bands handcrafted in New York City, adorned with antique diamonds and precious gems perfect for wedding or stacking.

Stone Type

Diamond
Ruby
Sapphire
Emerald

Setting

Eternity
Half Band

Metal

Blackened Metal
Mixed Metal
Platinum
Rose Gold
Yellow Gold

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 2mm

Classic Hoop 2mm

Classic Hoop 2mm

Classic Hoop 2mm

Classic Hoop 2mm

Classic Hoop 2mm

$1,500

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

$2,150

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

$2,150

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

Classic Hoop 3mm

$2,150

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 4mm

Classic Hoop 4mm

Classic Hoop 4mm

Classic Hoop 4mm

$2,000

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 4mm

Classic Hoop 4mm

Classic Hoop 4mm

Classic Hoop 4mm

$2,000

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop Brushed 4mm

Classic Hoop Brushed 4mm

Classic Hoop Brushed 4mm

Classic Hoop Brushed 4mm

$2,000

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop Brushed 4mm

Classic Hoop Brushed 4mm

Classic Hoop Brushed 4mm

Classic Hoop Brushed 4mm

$2,000

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 5mm

Classic Hoop 5mm

Classic Hoop 5mm

$2,200

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 6mm

Classic Hoop 6mm

Classic Hoop 6mm

$3,000

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Flat Hoop 6mm

Flat Hoop 6mm

Flat Hoop 6mm

Flat Hoop 6mm

$3,000

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Flat Hoop 6mm

Flat Hoop 6mm

Flat Hoop 6mm

Flat Hoop 6mm

$3,000

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Classic Hoop 10mm

Classic Hoop 10mm

Classic Hoop 10mm

$4,500

Erstwhile
Ready to Ship

Tempus Fugit | Platinum | Size 6

Tempus Fugit | Platinum | Size 6

Tempus Fugit | Platinum | Size 6

$2,650 $1,500

Erstwhile
Made To Order

Zeta

Zeta

Zeta

Pricing Upon Request

1
2
3

Your Cart

Your cart is currently empty.

Continue Shopping

Discover Products

Erstwhile Collection

Vintage Collection

Since 2010, Erstwhile has been a coveted NYC destination for antique and vintage engagement rings. Guided by an appreciation for all things bygone and a commitment to quality, Erstwhile also curates collectible vintage rings, wedding bands and namesake handcrafted pieces set with antique diamonds.

CONTACT US

We are open Monday — Friday | 10am — 6pm EST

Call: 212-390-1144

Email: info@erstwhilejewelry.com

Visit: 589 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY | Book an Appointment

JOIN THE HUNT

Sign up for early access to rare vintage engagement rings, antique finds, and new By Erstwhile drops.

Customer Care

Ring Sizing
Warranty & Repairs
Return Policy
Payment Options & Financing
Shipping
FAQ's

About Us

Our Story
Our Standards
Blog
Reviews
Stockists

Services

Custom Engagement Rings
Set Your Stone
Concierge Service
Gem Certification

©2026 Erstwhile Jewelry, all rights reserved

Instagram
Pinterest
Tiktok

Terms & Conditions
Privacy
Accessibility