Subscribe
Subscribe

valentine's day
GIFT GUIDE

Our Erstwhile gift guide offers timeless classics—souvenirs of affection to make hearts melt and romance blossom!
START SHOPPING

NEW ARRIVALS

explore our latest vintage acquisitions & creations
shop now
shop now
New Arrival
Oval Leia 1.03 Oval Leia 1.03

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Oval Leia 1.03

$11,200
In Stock

Black Rose 1.09 Black Rose 1.09

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Black Rose 1.09

$9,650
In Stock
New Arrival
Strela .95 Strela .95

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Strela .95

$13,100
In Stock
New Arrival
Art Nouveau 22k Yellow Gold Wedding Band Art Nouveau 22k Yellow Gold Wedding Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Art Nouveau 22k Yellow Gold Wedding Band

Sold
New Arrival
Antique Victorian Five-stone Ruby Ring Antique Victorian Five-stone Ruby Ring

Vintage Cocktail Rings

Antique Victorian Five-stone Ruby Ring

$2,500
In Stock
vintage engagement rings

VINTAGE ENGAGEMENT RINGS

fall in love with your dream vintage ring
shop now
shop now
New Arrival
Victorian 1.27 Carat Cushion Cut Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring Victorian 1.27 Carat Cushion Cut Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring

Vintage Engagement Rings

Victorian 1.27 Carat Cushion Cut Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring

$17,500
In Stock
New Arrival
Victorian 1.53 Carat Rose Cut Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring Victorian 1.53 Carat Rose Cut Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring

Vintage Engagement Rings

Victorian 1.53 Carat Rose Cut Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring

$11,500
In Stock
New Arrival
Art Deco 1.05 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring, Tiffany Art Deco 1.05 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring, Tiffany

Tiffany & Co.

Art Deco 1.05 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring, Tiffany

$14,000
In Stock
New Arrival
Art Deco 2.06 Carat Marquise Diamond Engagement Ring, Marcus & Co. Art Deco 2.06 Carat Marquise Diamond Engagement Ring, Marcus & Co.

Vintage Engagement Rings

Art Deco 2.06 Carat Marquise Diamond Engagement Ring, Marcus & Co.

$52,000
In Stock
New Arrival
Art Deco .75 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring Art Deco .75 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Vintage Engagement Rings

Art Deco .75 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

$6,000
In Stock

Edwardian Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring, Tiffany & Co. Edwardian Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring, Tiffany & Co.

Tiffany & Co.

Edwardian Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring, Tiffany & Co.

$10,200
In Stock

Victorian 1.07 Carat Old Mine Cushion Diamond Engagement Ring Victorian 1.07 Carat Old Mine Cushion Diamond Engagement Ring

Vintage Engagement Rings

Victorian 1.07 Carat Old Mine Cushion Diamond Engagement Ring

$15,000
In Stock
New Arrival
Vintage Edwardian .46 Carat Oval Cut Ruby Engagement Ring Vintage Edwardian .46 Carat Oval Cut Ruby Engagement Ring

Vintage Engagement Rings

Vintage Edwardian .46 Carat Oval Cut Ruby Engagement Ring

$6,000
In Stock

Victorian Oval Rose Cut & Enamel Ring Victorian Oval Rose Cut & Enamel Ring

Vintage Engagement Rings

Victorian Oval Rose Cut & Enamel Ring

$6,000
In Stock

ERSTWHILE ENGAGEMENT RINGS

Engagement rings handmade by master craftsman in New York City set with antique diamonds
shop now
shop now

Ever 1.19 Ever 1.19

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Ever 1.19

$14,600
In Stock

Nimbus 1.16 Nimbus 1.16

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Nimbus 1.16

$13,100
In Stock

Prism Shifter 1.07 Prism Shifter 1.07

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Prism Shifter 1.07

$13,100
In Stock
New Arrival
Strela 1.37 Strela 1.37

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Strela 1.37

$17,350
In Stock

Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire 1.12 Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire 1.12

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire 1.12

$8,950
In Stock

Strela 1.13 Strela 1.13

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Strela 1.13

In Production
Ready in 1 week

One For You 1.10 One For You 1.10

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

One For You 1.10

$10,600
In Stock

Knife Edge 1.24 Knife Edge 1.24

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Knife Edge 1.24

$14,650
In Stock
New Arrival
Strela .95 Strela .95

Erstwhile Engagement Rings

Strela .95

$13,100
In Stock

WEDDING BANDS

Erstwhile and vintage wedding bands

shop now
shop now
New Arrival
1960s 2.00 Carat Carré Cut Ruby Eternity Band, Tiffany & Co. 1960s 2.00 Carat Carré Cut Ruby Eternity Band, Tiffany & Co.

Vintage Wedding Bands

1960s 2.00 Carat Carré Cut Ruby Eternity Band, Tiffany & Co.

$4,500
In Stock
New Arrival
Mid Century Engraved Platinum Wedding Band Mid Century Engraved Platinum Wedding Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Mid Century Engraved Platinum Wedding Band

$900
In Stock
New Arrival
Mid Century .85 Carat Diamond Eternity Band Mid Century .85 Carat Diamond Eternity Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Mid Century .85 Carat Diamond Eternity Band

$3,000
In Stock

Mid Century Ruby & Diamond Half Band Mid Century Ruby & Diamond Half Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Mid Century Ruby & Diamond Half Band

$1,600
In Stock

Art Deco 1.25 Carat Carré Cut Ruby Eternity Wedding Band Art Deco 1.25 Carat Carré Cut Ruby Eternity Wedding Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Art Deco 1.25 Carat Carré Cut Ruby Eternity Wedding Band

$2,800
In Stock

Art Deco 22k Gold Classic Wedding Band, Tiffany & Co. Art Deco 22k Gold Classic Wedding Band, Tiffany & Co.

Tiffany & Co.

Art Deco 22k Gold Classic Wedding Band, Tiffany & Co.

$1,550
In Stock

1960s Faceted Classic Platinum Wedding Band, Tiffany & Co. 1960s Faceted Classic Platinum Wedding Band, Tiffany & Co.

Tiffany & Co.

1960s Faceted Classic Platinum Wedding Band, Tiffany & Co.

$1,600
In Stock

Art Deco Forget-Me-Not White Gold Wedding Band Art Deco Forget-Me-Not White Gold Wedding Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Art Deco Forget-Me-Not White Gold Wedding Band

$500
In Stock

Art Deco White Gold Forget Me Not Wedding Band Art Deco White Gold Forget Me Not Wedding Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Art Deco White Gold Forget Me Not Wedding Band

$575
In Stock

Late Art Deco White Gold Orange Blossom Wedding Band Late Art Deco White Gold Orange Blossom Wedding Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Late Art Deco White Gold Orange Blossom Wedding Band

$575
In Stock

Art Deco1.00 Carat Baguette Diamond Eternity Band Art Deco1.00 Carat Baguette Diamond Eternity Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

Art Deco1.00 Carat Baguette Diamond Eternity Band

$2,500
In Stock

Art Deco 2.00 Carat Baguette Cut Diamond Eternity Band, Tiffany & Co. Art Deco 2.00 Carat Baguette Cut Diamond Eternity Band, Tiffany & Co.

Tiffany & Co.

Art Deco 2.00 Carat Baguette Cut Diamond Eternity Band, Tiffany & Co.

$6,800
In Stock

1960s 2.50 Carat Carre Cut Diamond Eternity Wedding Band 1960s 2.50 Carat Carre Cut Diamond Eternity Wedding Band

Vintage Wedding Bands

1960s 2.50 Carat Carre Cut Diamond Eternity Wedding Band

$4,600
In Stock

CUSTOM ENGAGEMENT RINGS

Let us hunt for your dream diamond
explore
explore

Classic Emerald Cut Bezel Solitaire Classic Emerald Cut Bezel Solitaire

Erstwhile Custom Engagement Rings

Classic Emerald Cut Bezel Solitaire

STARTING FROM $7,625
made to order

Classic Asscher Cut Four Prong Solitaire Classic Asscher Cut Four Prong Solitaire

Erstwhile Custom Engagement Rings

Classic Asscher Cut Four Prong Solitaire

STARTING FROM $7,650
made to order

Prism Shifter Prism Shifter

Erstwhile Custom Engagement Rings

Prism Shifter

STARTING FROM $13,075
made to order

Golden Prism Shifter Golden Prism Shifter

Erstwhile Custom Engagement Rings

Golden Prism Shifter

STARTING FROM $13,075
made to order

RING WISHLIST

share the love
don't keep
it to yourself

CREATE AN ACCOUNT TO CURATE YOUR WISHLIST
Wishlist
CREATE AN ACCOUNT TO CURATE YOUR WISHLIST

SHOP BY STYLE

WORK WITH US IN OUR NEW YORK CITY SHOWROOM

Our antique jewelry experts have a vast knowledge in vintage engagement rings, old cut diamonds and other precious stones. They are able to help you find your unique piece for any occasion - from the Victorian era all way to our modern Erstwhile settings.

Come see us in our New York City showroom to find your dream piece. You can make an appointment in person or virtually and ask all your burning questions, request band pairings, or just chat :)


Make an appointment today!

JOURNAL

We're Popping up in LA!
We're Popping up in LA!
READ MORE