shop engagement rings in New York City
shop engagement rings in New York City

Visit Our NYC Showroom

Book an Appointment

Engagement Rings

Shop our curated collection of authentic vintage and antique engagement rings, plus handcrafted designs set with natural antique diamonds.

Carat Size
Stone Type
Setting
Metal
Ring Size
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
1.80ct Old European Cut Low-Profile Solitaire Engagement Ring | Seren
Seren 1.80ct old European cut diamond solitaire ring with low-profile setting in yellow gold

Seren 1.80

$18,375
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
2.09ct Antique Square Emerald Cut Engagement Ring | Strata
2.09ct Antique Square Emerald Cut Engagement Ring | Strata

Strata 2.09

$24,600
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
1.81ct Old European Cut Bezel Engagement Ring | Solara
Solara 1.81ct antique old European cut bezel-set engagement ring in 18k yellow gold

Solara 1.81

$14,000
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
1.56ct Fancy Intense Yellow Oval Diamond Engagement Ring | Aurelia
Aurelia ring with 1.56ct Fancy Intense Yellow oval diamond and old European cut side stones in platinum

Aurelia 1.56

$19,500
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
1.50ct Emerald Cut Engagement Ring with Baguette Diamonds | Luma
1.50ct Emerald Cut Engagement Ring with Baguette Diamonds | Luma

Luma 1.50

$11,800
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
1.96ct Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring | Mira
Mira 1.96ct old European cut diamond engagement ring in 18k yellow gold with six-prong crown

Mira 1.96

$23,000
Custom Engagement Rings
Custom Engagement Rings
learn more
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
4.42ct Old Mine Cut Diamond Yellow Gold Engagement Ring | One For You
Celeste 3.06 Carat Antique Three Stone Old Mine Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

One For You 4.42

$52,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Art Deco 1.60 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Onyx Halo Vintage Engagement Ring, France
Art Deco 1.60 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Onyx Halo Vintage Engagement Ring, France

Art Deco 1.60 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Onyx Halo Vintage Engagement Ring, France

$19,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Cartier Mid-Century 1.08 Carat Round Brilliant Cut Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring - on a hand
Cartier Mid-Century 1.08 Carat Round Brilliant Cut Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring

Cartier Mid-Century 1.08 Carat Round Brilliant Cut Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring

$14,500
CARTIER
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Pink Tourmaline Cluster Engagement Ring 18K Yellow Gold Vintage - Leia - on a hand
Pink Tourmaline Cluster Engagement Ring 18K Yellow Gold Vintage - Leia

Pink Tourmaline Leia 2.17

$8,800
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Victorian 3.67 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Solitaire Antique Engagement Ring - on a model
Victorian 3.67 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Solitaire Antique Engagement Ring

Victorian 3.67 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Solitaire Antique Engagement Ring

$42,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Art Deco 1.03 Carat Old Mine Diamond & Ruby Platinum Antique Engagement Ring
Art Deco 1.03 Carat Old Mine Diamond & Ruby Platinum Antique Engagement Ring

Art Deco 1.03 Carat Old Mine Diamond & Ruby Platinum Antique Engagement Ring

$12,000
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Prism Shifter 2.09
Prism Shifter 2.09

Prism Shifter 2.09

$26,800
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
2.29Ct Vintage Tiffany & Co. Diamond Solitaire
Vintage Iconic Tiffany & Co. 2.29 Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire

Vintage Tiffany & Co. 2.29 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring

$35,000
TIFFANY & CO.
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
1.55Ct Old Mine Diamond Solitaire in Yellow Gold | Astrid
1.55Ct Old Mine Diamond Solitaire in Yellow Gold | Astrid

Astrid 1.55

$13,600
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Art Moderne Platinum Diamond & Sapphire Bombé Ring
Art Moderne Old European Diamond & Sapphire Flush Mount Bombé Ring

Vintage Art Moderne Platinum Diamond & Sapphire Bombé Ring

$8,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Art Deco .76 Carat Transitional Cut Diamond & Baguette Platinum Engagement Ring
Art Deco Transitional & Baguette Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Art Deco .76 Carat Transitional Cut Diamond & Baguette Platinum Engagement Ring

$7,750
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Mid Century 1.04 Carat Asscher Cut Three Stone Engagement Ring
Mid Century 1.04 Carat Asscher Cut Three Stone Engagement Ring

Mid-Century 1.04 Carat Asscher Cut Diamond Three Stone White Gold Engagement Ring

$7,200
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Cassiopeia 1.74
1.74 Ct Marquise Diamond Gold Engagement Ring | Cassiopeia

Cassiopeia 1.74

$18,700
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Boucheron Art Deco 5.96 Carat Asscher Cut Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring
Boucheron Art Deco 5.96 Carat Asscher Cut Diamond Ring

Boucheron Art Deco 5.96 Carat Asscher Cut Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring

$125,000
BOUCHERON
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Impressive Art Deco 5.20 Carat Asscher Cut Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring
Impressive Art Deco 5.20 Carat Asscher Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Impressive Art Deco 5.20 Carat Asscher Cut Diamond Vintage Engagement Ring

$128,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Victorian 1.29 Carat Old Mine Cushion Buttercup Engagement Ring
Victorian 1.29 Carat Old Mine Cushion Buttercup Engagement Ring

Victorian 1.25 Carat Old Mine Cushion Buttercup Belcher Engagement Ring

$9,500
589 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK NY
Visit Our NYC Showroom
Explore our entire array of antique and vintage inspired Erstwhile engagement rings.
Visit us in our New York City showroom to find your dream piece. Visit us in person or virtually.
BOOK AN APPOINTMENT