engagement rings

Engagement Rings

From Past to Present: Timeless Vintage Beauty & Unmatched Craftsmanship

The destination for Erstwhile's renowned collection of unique vintage engagement rings and our handcrafted pieces set with rare antique diamonds.

Era
Carat Size
Stone Type
Stone Cut
Setting
Metal
Ring Size
103 Products
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Art Deco .97 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Ring - Erstwhile Jewelry
Art Deco .97 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Ring - Erstwhile Jewelry

Art Deco .97 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Ring

$15,500
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Edwardian Bezel Set 1.83 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Ring
Vintage Rings Edwardian Bezel Set 1.83 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Ring

Edwardian Bezel Set 1.83 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Ring

$14,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Vintage Tiffany & Co. 1.07 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire
Vintage Rings Vintage Tiffany & Co. 1.07 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire

Vintage Tiffany & Co. 1.07 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire

$13,000
Tiffany & Co.
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Midcentury 2.24 Carat Square Emerald Cut Diamond Ring
Vintage Rings Midcentury 2.24 Carat Square Emerald Cut Diamond Ring

Midcentury 2.24 Carat Square Emerald Cut Diamond Ring

$55,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Art Deco Sapphire & Diamond Three-Stone Ring
Vintage Rings Art Deco Sapphire & Diamond Three-Stone Ring

Art Deco Sapphire & Diamond Three-Stone Ring

$8,500
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Tiffany & Co. Midcentury 1.02 Carat Transitional Cut Diamond Ring
Vintage Rings Tiffany & Co. Midcentury 1.02 Carat Transitional Cut Diamond Ring

Tiffany & Co. Midcentury 1.02 Carat Transitional Cut Diamond Ring

$16,000
Tiffany & Co.
Custom & Stone Reset
learn more
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Victorian 4.20 Carat Old Mine Diamond Cluster Ring
Vintage Rings Victorian 4.20 Carat Old Mine Diamond Cluster Ring

Victorian 4.20 Carat Old Mine Diamond Cluster Ring

$75,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Edwardian 2.70 Carat Ceylon Sapphire & Diamond Cluster
Vintage Rings Edwardian 2.70 Carat Ceylon Sapphire & Diamond Cluster

Edwardian 2.70 Carat Ceylon Sapphire & Diamond Cluster

$12,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Art Deco 1.03 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Ring - Erstwhile Jewelry
Art Deco 1.03 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Ring - Erstwhile Jewelry

Art Deco 1.03 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Ring

$10,500
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
1920s 1.86 Carat Emerald Cut Fancy Intense Yellow Diamond Ring
1920s 1.86 Carat Emerald Cut Fancy Intense Yellow Diamond Ring

1920s 1.86 Carat Emerald Cut Fancy Intense Yellow Diamond Ring

$35,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Victorian 1.65 Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring
Vintage Rings Victorian 1.65 Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring

Victorian 1.65 Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring

$12,500
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Edwardian 1.05 Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Vintage Rings Edwardian 1.05 Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Edwardian 1.05 Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

$8,900
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Art Deco Old Mine Cut Diamond Domed Cluster Ring
Vintage Rings Art Deco Old Mine Cut Diamond Domed Cluster Ring

Art Deco Old Mine Cut Diamond Domed Cluster Ring

$9,500
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings J.E. Caldwell & Co. Late Art Deco 2.02 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Cluster
Vintage Rings J.E. Caldwell & Co. Late Art Deco 2.02 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Cluster

J.E. Caldwell & Co. Late Art Deco 2.02 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Cluster

$42,000
J.E. Caldwell & Co.
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Erstwhile Rings One For You 2.45 One For You Old Mine Cut Diamond Cut Down Mounting Blackened Metal Engagement Ring
Erstwhile Rings One For You 2.45 One For You Old Mine Cut Diamond Cut Down Mounting Blackened Metal Engagement Ring

One For You 2.45

$19,000
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Art Deco 1.60 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Domed Ring
Art Deco 1.60 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Domed Ring - Erstwhile Jewelry

Art Deco 1.60 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Domed Ring

$22,800
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Victorian Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring
Vintage Rings Victorian Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring

Victorian Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring

$7,800
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Art Deco 1.64 Carat Round Diamond Engagement Ring - Erstwhile Jewelry
Art Deco 1.64 Carat Round Diamond Engagement Ring - Erstwhile Jewelry

Art Deco 1.64 Carat Round Diamond Engagement Ring

$31,500
Tiffany & Co.
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Edwardian 1.33 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Cluster
Vintage Rings Edwardian 1.33 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Cluster

Edwardian 1.33 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Cluster

$12,500
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Victorian 1.11 Carat Old Mine Cut Solitaire
Vintage Rings Victorian 1.11 Carat Old Mine Cut Solitaire

Victorian 1.11 Carat Old Mine Cut Solitaire

$8,500
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Midcentury Old European Cut Diamond Toi et Moi Ring
Vintage Rings Midcentury Old European Cut Diamond Toi et Moi Ring

Midcentury Old European Cut Diamond Toi et Moi Ring

$40,500
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Vintage Rings Midcentury 3.02 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring Vintage Tiffany & Co. Midcentury 3.02 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Vintage Rings Midcentury 3.02 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring Vintage Tiffany & Co. Midcentury 3.02 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Midcentury 3.02 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

$80,000
Tiffany & Co.
589 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK NY
Visit Our NYC Showroom
Our antique jewelry experts have a vast knowledge in vintage engagement rings, old cut diamonds and gems. They are able to help you find your unique piece for any occasion, from the Victorian era to modern Erstwhile settings.
Visit us in our New York City showroom to find your dream piece. You can make an appointment in person or virtually.
BOOK AN APPOINTMENT