Testimonials

"I purchased online from the site and I am very than happy to give a five star review! Amazing customer service, amazing quality vintage and antique jewelry, beautiful thoughtful packaging (when it shipped to me) which makes the entire experience wrapped up in the bow and perfect. They also have a fantastic return policy and shipped it out within just a couple days!

We will definitely be purchasing jewelry from Erstwhile in the future. I only shop vintage/antique jewelry and have seen nothing but the very very best quality vintage on their site (after thoroughly searching high and low online), and now also seeing the confirmation in person having just received my vintage wedding ring from Erstwhilel.

The wedding ring we ordered was in perfect condition and from 1905! Incredible. Will definitely be a returning customer.

Thank you again Jesse for your wonderful help and customer service!"

Jos G., Chicago, IL, Yelp

"After eyeing Erstwhile's Instagram feed for months, I finally took the leap and bought a diamond eternity band. I had VERY high expectations, and Erstwhile far exceeded them. The service, start to finish, was a dream, and when the package arrived, I felt like I was unveiling a treasure. All of the details were incredibly thoughtful, and the ring is gorgeous and so special. I had been nervous about making such an important and personal purchase online, but I could not be happier that I did. I can't wait to buy another treasure from Erstwhile (and to eventually get to the store in NY!)."

Jessica L., Los Angeles, CA, Yelp

"My experience buying an engagement ring with Kat from Erstwhile was incredible and the whole process was stress free from start to finish. From the initial meeting in the showroom, through to purchase and re-sizing she was super helpful and it was seamless. I looked around for vintage engagement rings but always kept coming back to Erstwhile. Is their jewelry more expensive than something modern? Probably, but their pieces are beautiful and unique and my partner is absolutely in love with her ring which is all that matters."

Shannon Beneforti, Google

"Finally getting around to this review after 2 years. I wanted something very special that no one else has and boy did Erstwhile deliver!!! Being from Texas spending that kind of money placing a online order made me a bit nervous. These people provided top notch white glove service and way over delivered on every level. I HIGHLY recommend. Now I want a special necklace to go with my rings!"

Cherie Laake, Google

"I had the pleasure of working with Erstwhile for both my engagement ring and our wedding bands, and I have nothing but good things to say! The team is responsive and fabulous to work with, and the rings, of course, are stunning!"

Carrie Schmaus, Google