Free Shipping • Extended Holiday Return Window • 0% Financing with Affirm at Checkout Free Shipping • Extended Holiday Return Window • 0% Financing with Affirm at Checkout
  • New Arrivals
  • Engagement
  • Bands
  • Jewelry
  • Custom
  • Book an Appointment
  • Contact
  • About
  • Standards
  • New Arrivals
  • Engagement Rings
    • Shop All
    • Vintage Engagement Rings
    • Engagement Rings By Erstwhile
    • Vintage Tiffany & Co.
  • Wedding Bands
    • Vintage Bands
    • Wedding Bands By Erstwhile
    • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Custom Engagement Rings
  • Contact Us
  • Book An Appointment
  • Return Policy
  • About Us
  • Account
  • Wishlist
Collection
  • View All
  • Vintage Engagement Rings
  • Erstwhile Engagement Rings
  • Classic Solitaire Collection
  • Vintage Tiffany & Co.
  • Custom & Stone Reset
  • Sold
Era
  • Victorian
  • Edwardian
  • Art Deco
  • Mid Century
Setting
  • Solitare
  • Three Stone
  • Cluster
  • Halo
  • Bezel
  • Navette
Cut
  • Old European Cut
  • Old Mine Cushion Cut
  • Emerald Cut
  • Asscher Cut
  • Marquise Cut
  • Rose Cut
Metal
  • Platinum
  • Yellow Gold
  • Rose Gold
  • Two Tone
Erstwhile Engagement Rings
Vintage Engagement Rings
Collection
  • Vintage Bands
  • Erstwhile Bands
  • Bands for Him
Metal
  • Platinum Bands
  • Blackened Metal Bands
  • Gold Bands
  • Rose Gold Bands
Style
  • Eternity Bands
  • Diamond Bands
  • Plain Bands
  • Sapphire Bands
Erstwhile Bands
Bands For Him
Vintage
  • All Vintage Jewelry
  • Vintage Cocktail Rings
  • Vintage Necklaces
  • Vintage Bracelets
  • Vintage Earrings
By Erstwhile
  • All Jewelry By Erstwhile
About
  • Custom Design Process
  • Custom Engagement Ring Gallery
  • Customizable Settings

Yellow Gold Engagement Rings

Carat Size
Stone Type
Setting
Metal
Ring Size
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Bezel Solitaire Engagement Ring 2.01
Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Bezel Solitaire Engagement Ring 2.01

Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Bezel Solitaire Engagement Ring 2.01

$29,250
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Prism Shifter 2.03
Prism Shifter 2.03

Prism Shifter 2.03

$23,300
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
One For You 1.65
One For You 1.65

One For You 1.65

$27,900
  • Vintage
  • Ready to Ship
Victorian 4.20 Carat Old Mine Cushion Diamond Cluster Antique Engagement Ring
Victorian 4.20 Carat Old Mine Cushion Diamond Cluster Antique Engagement Ring

Victorian 4.20 Carat Old Mine Cushion Diamond Cluster Antique Engagement Ring

$75,000
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
3.07Ct Old Mine Diamond Bezel Engagement Ring in Yellow Gold
3.07Ct Old Mine Diamond Bezel Engagement Ring in Yellow Gold

Classic Old Mine Cushion Cut Diamond Bezel Solitaire Engagement Ring 3.07

$35,000
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring 2.01
Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire 2.01

Classic Asscher Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring 2.01

$25,100
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
1.79Ct Old European Cut Diamond Bezel Solitaire Yellow Gold Engagement Ring
1.79Ct Old European Cut Diamond Bezel Solitaire 18K Gold Engagement Ring

Classic Old European Cut Diamond Bezel Solitaire Engagement Ring 1.79

$19,750
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Juno 1.52
Juno 1.52

Juno 1.52

$19,300
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
1.27ct Old European Cut Three-Stone Engagement Ring | Strela
Strela 1.27 old European cut three-stone engagement ring in 18k yellow gold

Strela 1.27

$15,000
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Classic Emerald Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring 1.70
Classic Emerald Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire 1.70

Classic Emerald Cut Diamond Four Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring 1.70

$22,000
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Cyllene 1.72
Cyllene 1.72

Cyllene 1.72

$17,925
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Oval Leia 1.53ct Edwardian Cluster Engagement Ring
Cluster Engagement Ring 18K Yellow Gold Vintage Oval Diamond - Leia

Oval Leia 1.53

$14,600
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
2.05 Ct Old Mine Cushion Cut Diamond Solitaire 18K Engagement Ring
2.05 Ct Old Mine Cushion Cut Diamond Solitaire 18K Engagement Ring

Astrid 2.05

$17,500
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Prism Shifter 1.10
Prism Shifter 1.10

Prism Shifter 1.10

$12,300
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Dawn 1.51
Dawn 1.51

Dawn 1.51

$17,250
  • Erstwhile
  • Ready to Ship
Stella 2.14
Stella 2.14

Stella 2.14

$25,100
  • 1
  • 2
Your Cart
Your cart is currently empty.
Continue Shopping
Discover Products
Erstwhile Collection
Vintage Collection

Since 2010, Erstwhile has been a coveted NYC destination for antique and vintage engagement rings. Guided by an appreciation for all things bygone and a commitment to quality, Erstwhile also curates collectible vintage rings, wedding bands and namesake handcrafted pieces set with antique diamonds.

CONTACT US

We are open Monday — Friday | 10am — 6pm EST

Call: 212-390-1144

Email: info@erstwhilejewelry.com

Visit: 589 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY | Book an Appointment

JOIN THE HUNT

Sign up for early access to rare vintage engagement rings, antique finds, and new By Erstwhile drops.

Customer Care
  • Ring Sizing
  • Warranty & Repairs
  • Return Policy
  • Payment Options & Financing
  • Shipping
  • FAQ's
About Us
  • Our Story
  • Our Standards
  • Journal
  • Reviews
  • Stockists
Services
  • Custom Engagement Rings
  • Set Your Stone
  • Concierge Service
  • Gem Certification
©2025 Erstwhile Jewelry, all rights reserved
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Tiktok
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility