Antique & Vintage Engagement Rings

Visit Us in NYC or Virtually
Book an Appointment

Shop our curated collection of authentic vintage engagement rings, each piece is one-of-a-kind hand-selected for its character and craftsmanship.

Every ring in this collection is true vintage or antique. Antique engagement rings are over 100 years old, including Georgian (1714–1837), Victorian (1837–1900), and Edwardian (1901–1915) pieces. Vintage rings are at least 50 years old and include Art Deco (1920–1935), Retro (1939–1950), and Midcentury (1950–1970) designs.

FAQS: VINTAGE ENGAGEMENT RINGS

How old does a ring have to be to be considered vintage?

A ring is typically considered vintage when it is at least 50 years old. This includes styles from the Art Deco (1920–1935), Retro (1939–1950), and Midcentury (1950–1970) periods. Rings over 100 years old, such as Georgian, Victorian, or Edwardian pieces, are classified as antique.

Why choose a vintage engagement ring?

Vintage engagement rings offer unique styles no longer made due to lost art and craftsmanship, rare antique diamond cuts, and historic design details that aren’t found in modern mass-produced rings. They are also a more sustainable choice, since they repurpose existing materials.

Are vintage engagement rings more affordable?

Not always. While some vintage rings may be less costly than comparable modern pieces, many are rare and collectible. The scarcity of antique diamonds and the quality of period craftsmanship can make certain vintage rings more valuable than new designs. It’s also often more expensive to recreate a detailed antique piece than to purchase the original — we’re frequently asked to replicate intricate designs that would be cost prohibitive to produce today.

How can I tell if a vintage engagement ring is authentic?

Authenticity comes from age, craftsmanship, and provenance. At Erstwhile, every vintage engagement ring is carefully vetted, with antique diamonds and settings examined for historical accuracy and integrity.

Can vintage engagement rings be customized or resized?

Yes. Many vintage settings can be resized, and we also create custom recreations inspired by original vintage designs. This allows clients to capture the look and feel of a historic ring while ensuring the perfect fit and design details set with antique diamonds.

Are vintage engagement rings sustainable?

Yes. By choosing a vintage engagement ring, you’re extending the life of an existing diamond and setting. This reduces the need for new mining and makes vintage rings an environmentally responsible choice.

Visit Our Showroom
Discover a hidden gem in the heart of New York City's bustling Diamond District at Erstwhile's showroom. Explore our collection of unique vintage and handcrafted antique diamond engagement rings.
Your hand, our rings—it's a match made in vintage heaven.

What Our Customers Say